roundups
Best Seed Starting Trays 2026
Top seed starting trays compared by durability, drainage, and cell count: Bootstrap Farmer, Jiffy pellet trays, and 1020 insert options.
The best seed starting tray for most home gardeners is the Bootstrap Farmer 1020 Heavy Duty Tray paired with a 72-cell insert — it survives 5+ growing seasons, drains cleanly, and holds a standard humidity dome. For beginners who want zero transplant fuss, a Jiffy 72-Pellet Greenhouse Starter Tray lets you plant directly into peat pellets and drop the whole thing in the ground. Both work; which one you need depends on how many seasons you plan to reuse it.
What to look for in a seed starting tray
Bottom tray thickness. Most cheap 1020 flats crack within one season when lifted while full of wet soil and inserts. Thicker polypropylene (Bootstrap Farmer, HTG Supply) bows less and lasts five or more years with proper care. The difference in cost — $3 vs $8 per tray — pays back quickly once you stop replacing cracked flats each spring.
Cell count and volume. More cells means smaller individual cell volume. 72-cell is the all-purpose standard for most vegetables and herbs (roughly 5 cubic inches per cell). 128-cell is better for small-seeded flowers and plugs where you have dozens of varieties. 50-cell or larger gives brassicas and tomatoes more root volume before transplanting, reducing root-bound stress.
Drainage design. Cell inserts need proper drainage holes and a bottom tray below them to collect water. Avoid trays where drainage slits are too narrow — they clog with coir or peat and cause waterlogging. Good inserts have clean-cut round holes, not slits.
Peat vs. inert cell material. Peat and coir pellet trays (Jiffy, Burpee) are fill-and-water — no separate growing medium needed. They compress flat for storage, expand when watered, and many are transplant-direct (pellet goes in the ground). The tradeoff: they cost more per start than reusing a cell insert, and the mesh netting on some pellets can slow root penetration in clay soils.
Quick comparison
| Product | Best for | Rating | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bootstrap Farmer 1020 Heavy Duty Tray | best overall — thick, reusable bottom tray | ★★★★★ | About $6-9 each. Extra-strength polypropylene. Lasts 5+ seasons. No holes (bottom tray). | Check price |
| Bootstrap Farmer 72-Cell Insert | best insert for herbs and most vegetables | ★★★★★ | About $4-6 each. Pairs with 1020 bottom tray. Large drainage holes. Sturdy walls. | Check price |
| Jiffy 72-Pellet Greenhouse Tray | best for beginners — no soil mixing needed | ★★★★☆ | About $10-16 per tray. Peat pellets expand when watered. Direct transplant. Zero mess. | Check price |
| HTG Supply 1020 Tray with Humidity Dome | best budget starter set — tray and dome together | ★★★★☆ | About $8-14 for tray and dome. Adequate thickness for 2-3 seasons. Dome fits snugly. | Check price |
| Viagrow 128-Cell Plug Tray | best for bulk small-seeded starts | ★★★★☆ | About $3-5 each. 128 small cells for flowers and plugs. Standard 1020 footprint. | Check price |
The picks
Best overall: Bootstrap Farmer 1020 Heavy Duty Tray
Best for anyone who starts seeds every season and wants a tray that outlasts a decade of use
Bootstrap Farmer 1020 Extra Strength Seed Starting Tray
Bootstrap Farmer produces the most durable polypropylene 1020 trays available to home growers. At roughly 20-mil thickness (vs. 7-10 mil for hardware-store flats), these trays do not crack, bow, or split when lifted while full. The no-holes bottom tray holds water for bottom watering or catches overflow from cell inserts above it. Dimensions are true 1020 (20"x10") so standard domes and inserts from any brand seat correctly. A pack of five runs $30-45 and will outlast a decade of spring seed starts — a better investment than buying cheap trays every year.
★★★★★ 4.7 · 2,400 reviews
Check current price on Amazon→Pros
- Extra-thick polypropylene does not crack or bow when lifted full of wet soil and inserts
- True 1020 dimensions — compatible with all standard domes and cell inserts
- Available with or without holes; no-holes version is better for bottom watering
- Lasts 5-10 seasons with basic care — lowest long-term cost per seed start
- Easy to clean: dilute bleach rinse removes pathogens between seasons
Cons
- More expensive per tray upfront ($6-9 vs $2-3 for cheap flats)
- No-holes version requires a separate cell insert to sow into
- Heavier than thin flats — minor inconvenience when stacking many empty trays
- Not sold in most retail garden centers; typically an online purchase
Best insert: Bootstrap Farmer 72-Cell Tray Insert
Best for herbs, tomatoes, peppers, and most vegetables where 5 cubic inches of cell volume is adequate
Bootstrap Farmer 72-Cell Seed Starting Insert Tray
The 72-cell insert from Bootstrap Farmer pairs with their own bottom tray and most standard 1020 flats. Cells are deeper than the cheap thin inserts you find at big-box stores, which means more root volume before transplanting and less root-bound stress on tomatoes and peppers. Drainage holes are generously sized and round — no clogging issues with coir or peat mixes. The walls between cells are thick enough that the insert does not collapse when lifted out of the bottom tray. At $4-6 per insert, these are reusable for several seasons with proper washing.
★★★★★ 4.6 · 1,800 reviews
Check current price on Amazon→Pros
- Deeper cells than big-box store inserts — more root volume for tomatoes and peppers
- Round drainage holes do not clog with peat or coir mixes
- Thick walls hold shape when lifting out of the bottom tray
- Pairs perfectly with Bootstrap Farmer 1020 bottom tray (compatible dimensions)
- Reusable for multiple seasons — better economics than single-use plastic inserts
Cons
- Requires a separate bottom tray — sold as insert only
- 72 cells is the only standard cell count available from this brand
- Slightly stiffer than thin inserts — cells do not pop out as easily at transplant time
- Online-only; not stocked at most local garden centers
Best for beginners: Jiffy 72-Pellet Greenhouse Starter Tray
Best for first-time seed starters who want to avoid soil mixing and transplanting stress
Jiffy 72-Pellet Expandable Peat Pellet Greenhouse Tray
Jiffy peat pellets expand from a compressed disk to a self-contained planting cell when watered — no soil measuring, no separate growing medium, no potting bench mess. Sow one or two seeds per pellet, thin to one seedling, and when ready to transplant, drop the whole pellet into the ground or a larger container. The mesh netting holds the pellet together and roots grow through it. This is the lowest-friction entry to seed starting: unwrap, add water, sow, and cover with the included dome. The 72-pellet tray handles a full season of herb starts or a mix of vegetables for a small garden.
★★★★☆ 4.4 · 3,200 reviews
Check current price on Amazon→Pros
- Zero soil preparation — pellets expand with water and are ready to sow immediately
- Direct transplant: the whole pellet goes in the ground, eliminating bare-root transplant shock
- Includes a humidity dome — complete kit out of the box
- Flat-packs for storage; takes almost no shelf space between seasons
- Great for beginners: no decisions about soil mix, drainage, or cell depth
Cons
- Higher cost per start than reusable cell inserts plus bulk potting mix
- Mesh netting can slow root establishment in heavy clay soils
- Single-use tray — the cardboard/plastic tray is not meant for multiple seasons
- Pellets are smaller than 72-cell insert cells — not ideal for large-seeded crops like squash
- Peat sourcing raises sustainability concerns; coir-based pellet alternatives exist
Best budget complete setup: HTG Supply 1020 Tray with Dome
Best for growers who want a tray-and-dome combo without paying Bootstrap Farmer prices
HTG Supply 1020 Seed Starting Flat with Humidity Dome
HTG Supply makes one of the better mid-grade 1020 trays: noticeably thicker than dollar-store flats, with a dome that fits snugly without gaps. The tray handles two to three seasons before showing stress, which is reasonable at its $8-14 price point for the tray-and-dome combo. This is the pick for growers who want a step up from the thinnest trays but are not ready to invest in Bootstrap Farmer's premium build. Pairs with standard 72-cell or 128-cell inserts from any brand.
★★★★☆ 4.3 · 980 reviews
Check current price on Amazon→Pros
- Mid-grade thickness handles 2-3 seasons without cracking under normal use
- Dome fits snugly — maintains humidity during germination without gaps
- True 1020 dimensions fit standard cell inserts and domes
- Available in packs of 5 or 10 at reasonable per-unit cost
- Widely available from hydroponics retailers and online
Cons
- Thinner than Bootstrap Farmer — will crack eventually, especially when lifted full
- Dome height is standard; taller domes (6-inch) sold separately for larger starts
- Not as long-lived as premium trays — plan to replace every 2-3 seasons
- HTG Supply brand is less well-known; availability varies by region
What to skip
The cheapest green 1020 flats at big-box garden centers. These are typically 4-7 mil polypropylene — they crack, bow, and split after one season. The $2 price is not worth it once they fall apart under a full load of wet soil. A Bootstrap Farmer tray pays for itself within two seasons.
Cell inserts with slit-style drainage holes. Narrow slits clog with peat or coir particles, waterlog cells, and cause damping-off. Look for round holes, and check that drainage actually works by running water through before your first sow.
Trays that don’t accept a standard 1020 dome. Off-brand trays occasionally have dimensions that are slightly off, leaving gaps under the dome that destroy humidity retention during germination. Buy a dome and tray from the same brand, or verify dimensions.
Foam plug trays for most home grows. Foam Oasis-style plug trays are excellent for commercial operations but expensive and overkill for home seed starting. Stick with polypropylene inserts unless you are propagating hundreds of cuttings at once.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
How many seeds should I put in each cell?
Do I need a humidity dome for seed starting trays?
How often should I water seeds in trays?
Can I reuse seed starting trays?
What size cell insert should I use for tomatoes?
When should I transplant seedlings out of their starting tray?
Bottom line
For the most durable setup, pair the Bootstrap Farmer 1020 bottom tray with their 72-cell insert — it will outlast a decade of seed starts and costs less per season than replacing cheap flats annually. If you want the simplest possible entry to seed starting, a Jiffy 72-Pellet greenhouse tray removes every friction point: add water, sow, cover, wait. For a budget tray-and-dome combo that outperforms hardware-store flats, the HTG Supply 1020 with dome handles two to three seasons reliably.
For everything else in your seed-starting setup, see our guides on how to start seeds indoors step by step, the best seed starting kits (heat mats, dome, and light bundles), the best seed starting soil mixes, and the best heat mats for seed germination.